It’s over

At about 10:30 this morning, my professor, Norman Finkelstein, announced that he had reached a settlement with DePaul University and, as part of that settlement, had agreed to resign, effective immediately. I had a feeling ever since his initial tenure denial in June that he would end up having to leave, but now that it’s officially over, it fucking sucks.

Granted, the settlement included public acknowledgment of his excellent teaching and his prolific career as a scholar, which undoes some of the shameless slander and defamation perpetrated by certain people at DePaul. However, the settlement leaves two vast injustices unchecked. These are: the way in which DePaul went about removing Finkelstein (He said that if they had simply and reasonably asked him to leave, he would have gone.) and the absolutely unforgivable denial of Professor Mehrene Larudee’s tenure, which, as near as anyone can tell, was solely do to her support of Professor Finkelstein.

I was involved with the student movement that supported Professor Finkelstein’s tenure bid since it first started in March. Our activities ranged from getting a petition signed to give to the President of the University before he made his decision, to occupying a room in the President’s office for three days after the initial denial, to marching on campus and rallying in front of the Political Science building. Although we failed in our ultimate goal, reversal of the Finkelstein and Larudee decisions and a formal apology from the school (and the resignations of basically everyone responsible for those decisions), our activism did allow for a wave of awareness among DePaul students of the importance of academic freedom, which is certainly a silver lining. For example, there is going to be an event on October 12 at the University of Chicago with Noam Chomsky, John Mearsheimer, Tony Judt, Neve Gordon, and Akeel Bilgrami, hosted by Tarip Ali, entitled “In Defense of Academic Freedom”, which DePaul students (not me) are involved in organizing. Also, the forming of the DePaul Academic Freedom Committee, which is the group that formed out of the initial Finkelstein support group after the tenure denials.

So, there are some pictures from the protest today that I’ll post later. You can also check out the Chicago Tribune’s website which has a story about the settlement, if you want to waste your time registering with them. They have a picture with me in it, but I’m only sorta visible.

By the way, today was also the first day of class.

Comments (8) left to “It’s over”

  1. Evan wrote:

    well, at least your semester will be a tad less busy…? sucksanywaythough.

  2. Emma wrote:

    Noooo, Finkelstein!!

    Please brainwash him into teaching at MCAD. Please.

  3. Timmy wrote:

    I guess being out of the loop doesn’t help, but what was your goodly professor’s significance, and hence the significance of him being denied tenure?

  4. brock-o-lock wrote:

    I was curious how far you feel your activism goes at (what i am assuming is) a private college, vs. a public establishment… It seems like private colleges can do whatever they politically want, as long as they are up to accredidation standards, where as a public university must be more careful not to burn bridges… Am i crazy?

  5. Allison wrote:

    chance LOOOOOOVEEESSSSSSS Finkelstein. loves.

  6. Evan wrote:

    tim, you are such a finkelstein.

  7. Chance wrote:

    Professor Finkelstein’s significance is kind of a long story. Basically, he is a fairly famous academic who, because of his beliefs on Israel-Palestine, is wrongly labeled an anti-semite and self-hating Jew by many people, particularly Alan Dershowitz of the Harvard Law School. It is because of pressure from Dershowitz and those who agree with him that DePaul denied his tenure.

    The significance of the tenure battle is that the denial of his and Professor Larudee’s tenure based on political grounds is an infringement upon academic freedom. He has the right to be secure in his job, regardless of his political beliefs, and we, as students, have the right to be exposed to those beliefs.

    If you want to know more, you can go to his website: Here.

  8. Timmy wrote:

    Very interesting, and also terribly unfortunate. It’s a shame that the nature of the argument as well as the people making them has led to people labeled as anti-semites. Interestingly, I’ve heard of other complaints of infringement on academic freedom by individuals who hold to objectivism being denied tenure.